Kenmore Vertical Gas Smoker Reviews


www.sears.com


4.56 of 5
(by 25 reviewers)
Rating Summary | Everyone recommends (25 out of 25)

Pros
  • holds steady temperature (5)
  • uses lp gas for long cooking times (4)
  • excellent smoked taste and tender meat (4)
  • reasonable price (3)
  • parts readily available (1)
  • temperature regulator is a plus (1)
Cons
  • needs a cover (2)
  • paint markings came off regulator knob (2)
  • could be better insulated (2)
  • size (1)
  • minute adjustments of temp is difficult. (1)
Most Helpful Favorable Review

Get this one!

I first tried the Kenmore electric smoker. It was terrible! The heating element wasn't powerful enough to get the temperature above 200F. The element then burned out after two months. After reading a few consumer reviews, I decided to give the propane model a try. Wow, what a difference. The propane... read full review »
Posted on Dec 12, 2008
Most Helpful Critical Review

good for the $

I bought it for the 4th of July and had a lot of compliments on the smoked meat.It is an ok unit, a little bit flimsy and no fun to clean, but overall a good investment. I would rather put the meat in and have fun with family and friends than stand over a charcoal smoker or a gas grill, and the meat... read full review »
Posted on Aug 21, 2008

Kenmore Vertical Gas Smoker Reviews

Displaying reviews 1 - 14 of 25 in total

I like this smoker for the space and sizes. It could be better sealed to hold in more of the smoke but it works okay.  Easy access through the front. Make sure you use larger chunks of wood - the chips get burned through pretty quickly.  Assembly was pretty simple, no challenges there.  So far so good, I'd recommend it BUT be aware that it doesn't hold all the smoke in.

 

Posted on May 31, 2010

This smoker has performed very well for me.  It absolutey provides a well smoked meat flavor.

The temperature stays where you set it (with the exception of a sudden increase or decrease in outside temperature.)  If your weather is pretty constant or makes slow changes throughout the day then you will be fine, but if you choose to use this on a day where a rain storm might appear or a day when a very hot sun is overhead, you must pay close attention to the temperature of the smoker or it will vary wildly.  But this can be a problem for any smoker.

The other problem I have is that I can set the...

read full review »
Posted on Mar 29, 2010

Great Product, Easy to use.

This is my second smoker, first was a charcoal smoker.  I wanted a smoker that would be more convenient, so I would not have to constantly watch it.  This smoker really fills the bill.  Using propane allows almost unattended cooking, along with the large wood chip box which lasts up to 1.5 hours and the large water pan.  With the burner set at about 1/2 this keeps a constant temp of 250 degrees, even in windy weather.  Buy this one, you won't be disappointed.

Posted on Oct 30, 2009

My brother has this unit and likes it.  My husband was quite interested in it, so I bought this as an early Christmas present for him.  What a terrific idea!  The unit is easy to use and the propane tank beats charcoal hands down.  My husband lines the drip pan with aluminum foil which makes it easier to clean.  We have smoked pork and fish thus far, and plan to smoke one of our Thanksgiving turkeys.  Surprisingly, the less expensive cuts of meat turn out the best ~ pork loin is good; pork shoulder is even better ~ probably because there's more marbled fat.  Smoked dilled salmon and smoked...

read full review »
Posted on Nov 20, 2009

The vertical gas smoker is well worth the price. As stated look for deals. I took the floor model for $150.  Bought it due to good reviews on "smoking" websites.

Had to put a handle on the wood chip box so I could remove it while hot.

The Unit does run hot, especially in the sun. Hard to keep below 250f. 

Gets hot enough to use as a spare oven. 450f is no problem.

Would have given 5 stars if the was a double walled model.

Posted on Aug 10, 2009

Excellent Smoker

I bought this smoker for my Dad as a Father's Day gift. Setting it up was easy, and cooking with it is so much easier than with a charcoal smoker. It maintains a constant temperature, so you don't have spend all day checking a thermometer and adding coals. Also, the racks come out easily and fit right in the dishwasher. My Dad has made pork loin, chicken and beef brisket so far, and everything was wonderful. This smoker is so awesome that my husband now wants one!
Posted on Aug 01, 2009

BUY THIS SMOKER

Love this smoker. Heat stays constant in all kinds of weather, (digital smokers will not work in cold temps), yes its gets cold around Thanksgiving and Christmas. Turkeys, chicken, ribs you name it does a great job. Everyone shows up now for the holidays and my ribs only get better, no need for charcoal. Only complaint is no custom made cover, only cheap ones on the market
Posted on Jun 26, 2009

This smoker makes food so good, your dog will fight you for the bone!

 I've used charcoal smokers for years, but this was my first gas smoker and it seemed to be a good value--and I wasn't disappointed. It's easy to regulate the heat and holds a steady temperature--225 seems to be the favorite for smoking, and the water pan doesn't have to refilled very often. The great thing is not having to add charcoal during long cooking times, like cooking overnight.

And the smoked flavor is excellent. Whole chickens turn out beautifully and I've also smoked ham, ribs and sausage and, as I write this, I'm...

read full review »
Posted on Nov 01, 2009

Help

I did not get a cookbook with my smoker and don't know what cookbook I need. Does anyone have any suggestions as to what cookbook to use? I have not used my smoker yet so I don't know how it cooks.
Posted on Jul 20, 2009

I have been looking at getting a smoker since christmas time.  I want to make venison snack sticks instead of paying an arm and a leg to have somebody else do it for me.  I have been all over and doing all kinds of research and had almost spent in excess of $200 depending on cabellas or bass pro.  The local sears hardware is going out of business and I seen they had the vertical propane smoker and it looked like it was everything I needed.  Not as insulated as I wanted but it would do for my purposes.  I came home and read your reviews and decided that the $179 dollar price tag marked down...

read full review »
Posted on Jun 01, 2009

Excellent value for the money

We spent a lot of time researching smokers. Sure we could have spent three and four times as much without getting a lot more for the money. It assembles easily and there are no problems with the gas fittings. There are three settings on the gas dial low, medium, and high. Not sure why they just didn't use a variable dial, but so far we have only needed the low setting smoking meat, fish, and making some fabulous pastrami. The temperature has been consistently accurate. The low setting gives a temperature of 210 degrees. I soak the wood chips overnight, and I get smoke lasting over an hour with... read full review »
Posted on Dec 06, 2008

Easy Smoking

I bought this smoker a couple of days ago. Assembly was simple. Smoking food is also simple. Just place food on rack and start. Being my trial run, I smoked some baby back ribs and 2 chickens. Man, it was delicious. I was impressed on the ease. Since it was cold outside, I had to adjust the thermostat, but, when adjusted, it cooked great. This is a good smoker to start with. I thought it would be too large; however, it is the right size. I would recommend buying this smoker.
Posted on Nov 25, 2008

Great smoker for the money!

I originally bought the electric version of this smoker and took it back because it wouldn't heat up over 200. This propane version is great! Now I just have to make sure I keep it at or below Medium or it gets too hot for slow smoking. It heats up and starts to smoke right away. I did find that the thermometer in the door reads out 50 degrees high ( I checked it with an oven thermometer). So make sure you check yours out. It has a much larger water pan and larger chip holder than the electric version. They don't sell a natural gas conversion kit so I am going to convert it myself after I am done... read full review »
Posted on Oct 11, 2008

great smoker

I have used my smoker every weekend since I bought it. I love it. Keeps a constant temperature and the smoker works perfectly.
Posted on Mar 06, 2009

Reviews of Kenmore Vertical Gas Smoker