I purchased Maybelline Line Stilletto during a sale at Rite Aid where Maybelline products were forty percent off. I bought the Lash Stilletto Mascara and I definitely needed to replace my liquid eyeliner, because it was old and messy and I just really needed to get some new stuff as a hygenic thing, I suppose. I purchased this product cheaply and was very happy with the results. I recommend using it with the lash Stilletto Mascara. Maybelline Line Stilletto makes it easy for anyone to draw a straight line over the eye or under the eye. It dosen't stain, smear, or clump, it glides on smooth like liquid liner should. There is no waste, because just a little comes out at a time. A little goes a long way. This doesn't flake off like some of the types of liquid liner you paint on do. It comes off smoothly with regular water. I like that. I can't stand having to nearly scale my eyes to get rid of the warpaint on my upper eyelid!