Wish for Joy 11-Piece Roaster Set Reviews


3.92 of 5
(by 13 reviewers)
Rating Summary | 92% of reviewers recommend (11 out of 13)

Pros
  • good (1)
Cons
  • None
Most Helpful Favorable Review

Roaster deluxe +

The price after rebate of $10 costs the buyer $4+. The roasting pan is large and has a grate, so the fat drips into the pan. The handles to pick the roaster up are awkward. One must hope this has no lead. It comes with a wooden cutting board, which might be OK to slice bread on. The set also includes... read full review »
Posted on Mar 01, 2008
Most Helpful Critical Review

To be fair you really do get what you pay for, the Wish for Joy 11-Piece Roaster Set is not the best roaster set but then it is not the most expensive set either. I picked this set up because I needed something to make kalhua Pork for a squadron BBQ and it did the job, I don't think it will last very...

read full review »
Posted on Nov 23, 2010

Wish for Joy 11-Piece Roaster Set Reviews

Displaying all 11 reviews

Rusted after first use

The product I was most excited about in this box set was the roasting pan itself. I was very disappointed. To be fair my one use was a prolonged one. I roasted a full 8 lb pork shoulder in the roasting set at 350 for about 5 hours. There was water in the roasting pan to prevent too much smoking, but it would periodically dry out and I would add more when noticed. Well after scrubbing the plan clean from this one use the paint / non stick coating came over on probably 20% of the cooking area. I then put the now chipped pan through the dishwasher for further cleaning, and it came out well rusted.... read full review »
Posted on May 22, 2008

Good basic product. I wonder why the roasting pan was not made of heavy guage stainless steel or a better titanium alloy ? There was not enought specifications on the materials used and coatings on the pan for us to make a better informed decision.

Posted on Dec 01, 2009

4 stars

Posted on Mar 16, 2008

Excellent value.

I am well pleased with my purchase from Sears, The initial price was good , stack the rebate on and it's fantastic! Will be using my roaster on the grill for the seasonal smoked turkey, and see no problems with the product. Thanks again Sears...
Posted on Mar 08, 2008

very pleased!

This is a box full of great things! Would be very nice for a house warming gift. I bought for myself and am very happy with the purchase. I chose to pick up at the store and got a notice only a couple of hours later that it was ready for pickup. A rebate, too!!
Posted on Mar 02, 2008

4 stars

Posted on Mar 01, 2008

4 stars

Posted on Mar 01, 2008

Tremendous!

What a tremendous value. For those few times a year when you need a full size roasting pan, this will be PERFECT! I chose to order on line and pick up in store and the experience was fantastic. Within 3 minutes of getting there, I was walking out with the box under my arm. Good going Sears!
Posted on Mar 01, 2008

5 stars

Posted on Feb 29, 2008

4 stars

Posted on Feb 29, 2008

Nice prduct

Good product for the price. Lots of extra little goodies in addition to the roaster pan.
Posted on Mar 01, 2008

Reviews of Wish for Joy 11-Piece Roaster Set